Skip to Content
reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000

What Magical Elves think of Lifetime’s version of Project Runway, the show they created

Besides having the best name in the reality TV production world, Magical Elves are responsible for a lot of other compelling series, from Bands on the Run (remember that?) to Top Chef. But they created a genre of reality television with Project Runway, and last fall, their show left their control as it moved to …

Read More about What Magical Elves think of Lifetime’s version of Project Runway, the show they created

Lifetime’s Project Runway finale down from Bravo, but was 2009’s top cable reality show

After a spectacular debut that was up 44 percent over Bravo, Lifetime’s version of Project Runway concluded with an episode that just barely surpassed its record-breaking opening episode, and was down from the season five season finale on Bravo–though not by as much as some would have you believe. And really, that just continues the …

Read More about Lifetime’s Project Runway finale down from Bravo, but was 2009’s top cable reality show

Lifetime’s Project Runway 6 finds a winner, and it’s not viewers

Seven months after the three finalists presented collections at Fashion Week, Project Runway 6 ended, with the win going to Irina Shabayeva. Although Heidi told her the judges were “disappointed in [her] lack of color,” Michael Kors said Irina had “the best sense of showmanship.” After she won, Heidi told her that her collection was …

Read More about Lifetime’s Project Runway 6 finds a winner, and it’s not viewers

Why Lifetime’s lifeless Project Runway is like the first Harry Potter movie

When Project Runway 6 first debuted on Lifetime, I was impressed. I’d been worried about the change of networks, never mind the change of locations from New York to L.A. But I mostly wasn’t convinced that the production company responsible for Real World could reproduce what Magical Elves created while inventing an entire subgenre and …

Read More about Why Lifetime’s lifeless Project Runway is like the first Harry Potter movie