Skip to Content
reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000

So You Think You Can Dance is back—with a (new) new format and an old judge

So You Think You Can Dance is back—with a (new) new format and an old judge
SYTYCD 18's new judges, Maksim Chmerkovskiy, Comfort Fedoke, Nigel Lythgoe and Allison Holker, with host Cat Deeley standing. (Photo by Nathan Bolster/FOX)

Here’s a holiday surprise I never expected: Fox’s So You Think You Can Dance is returning for its 18th season this spring, dusting off an old judge and debuting yet another new format.

After the 2019 season, the pandemic seemed to have killed its chances of returning, but it was back in summer of 2022, with a new format and new judges Stephen “tWitch” Boss and JoJo Siwa.

In the third judge chair, Leah Remini replaced Matthew Morrison, who was fired two episodes into the season because of his interaction with a contestant.

tWitch died last December at age 40.

While Cat Deeley is once again returning as host, SYTYCD 18 will have new judges.

A portrait of a man wearing a sport coat and black shirt in front of a white background
Nigel Lythgoe (Photo by Brooklin Rosenstock/FOX)

Back at the judging table will be co-creator Nigel Lythgoe, who didn’t want to leave when he was booted off the judge’s table for season 17.

He will be joined by former Dancing with the Stars pro Maksim Chmerkovskiy and So You Think You Can Dance alum Allison Holker. Allison married to tWitch in 2013, and they had three children.

So You Think You Can Dance alum and all-star Comfort Fedoke will also join the panel for auditions.

The prize for the new season, which will debut in early March, remains $100,000.

SYTYCD 18’s new format

So You Think You Can Dance host Cat Deeley on the SYTYCD 16 finale
So You Think You Can Dance host Cat Deeley on the SYTYCD 16 finale. (Photo by Adam Rose/FOX)

Fox’s reality TV president, Allison Wallach, said “So You Think You Can Dance is television’s preeminent dance competition, and we are thrilled to bring the beloved show back.”

While Cat and Nigel are returning, the show’s format is not. It also has a new showrunner, Daniel Martin, who’s also showrunner of Fox’s I Can See Your Voice and The Real Dirty Dancing, a show I really liked.

Fox describes So You Think You Can Dance’s new format as “reflecting the authentic experience of building a successful career in dance, as so many So You Think You Can Dance alums have.”

Here’s how the season will play out:

Each week, contestants will compete in new, intense dance challenges that will give them a real taste of the career, from performing in a music video or a football halftime show to going toe-to-toe on stage with a Broadway performer. In the end, it will be up to the judges to decide their fate. Eliminations will take place weekly, with the Top 3 finalists competing in the season’s spectacular finale, but only one will win the $100,000 grand prize and the highly coveted title of So You Think You Can Dance champion.

This is definitely a big shift away from the show’s choreographed performances of the past. So many of SYTYCD’s performances were just stunning works of art, and it’ll be sad to lose those.

Then again, that clearly wasn’t working to sustain the series, and I like the idea of putting dancers in real-world scenarios and testing them.

The logo for So You Think You Can Dance, with a purple background and a side view of a stylized dancer, with waves of color emanating from them

What matters is if the format allows them to showcase their talent and artistry.

The reality TV show itself will change, too, adding what Fox called “new storytelling elements to further capture the authentic ups and downs experienced by professional dancers.” Here’s what we’ll see:

For the first time ever, in addition to the big spectacle dance numbers that So You Think You Can Dance has long been famous for, viewers will get a documentary-style inside look at the contestants’ dynamics, following them throughout the competition as they go through their personal and competitive journeys, including the daily struggles, new relationships, personality clashes and more.

Fox says these changes “reflect and celebrate its consistency in launching illustrious dance careers for its contestants, who can be found in the dance troupes for superstar musical acts, on Broadway stages, on every dance show on TV and beyond.”

While that may be a lofty ambition, the show certainly has produced an impressive group of alumni.

The promise of backstage drama is a little worrying, especially considering Fox’s recent talent competitions have been less interested in the work and more interested in the people (see the increasingly disappointing Lego Masters and the flat Hot Wheels: Ultimate Challenge for examples).

That said, I’m actually excited to see SYTYCD try to shift into a competition that gives us a sense of what those professional dancers’ lives are actually like while also showcasing their talent.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

About the writer

Discussion: your turn

The writing here is the start of a conversation, and reality blurred values your contributions to that conversation. We’ve created a community that connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching, the pop culture we’re consuming, and the stories about it.

To share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space, there are rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to those rules.

Happy discussing!

william miller

Thursday 22nd of February 2024

Glad Cat and Nigel are still part of show. My prayers go out to Allison.

Andy Dehnart

Thursday 22nd of February 2024

Nigel is not part of the show any more, now that he’s being sued by multiple people for sexual harassment and assault.


Friday 8th of December 2023

In other words going from "American Idol for dancers" to "America's Next Top Dancer Apprentice" ?


Thursday 7th of December 2023

So axing studio based shows then in favour of on location challenges?


Wednesday 6th of December 2023

The show also moves to Pullman Yards in Atlanta


Wednesday 6th of December 2023

New showrunner is the dude who did Real Dirty Dancing so....yeah