Skip to Content
reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000

Squid Game: The Challenge is even more bleak than the Netflix show it copies

Squid Game: The Challenge is even more bleak than the Netflix show it copies
Squid Game: The Challenge players learn about murder-free Red Light, Green Light (Image via Netflix)

Netflix’s Squid Game: The Challenge is a spectacular achievement in reality television competition, faithfully echoing Hwang Dong-hyuk’s hit Squid Game while inexplicably ignoring what Netflix itself describes as the drama’s “violent test of morality and humanity.”

Squid Game: The Challenge is immediately striking, especially with its visual landscape: The reality TV production has faithfully crafted the voluminous sets from the South Korean series, some of which never existed in real life, with elements created by special effects artists.

Into the first of these spaces, a massive enclosed courtyard, walk 456 contestants, dressed in green tracksuits adorned with their numbers. Masked guards, clad in pink suits covering their entire bodies, faces covered by a shield with a shape painted on it, stand nearby. Other guards watch the players from a control room.

The players have come from around the world to step inside their entertainment, the kind of immersion in a pop culture property that 007: Road to a Million failed to offer its players or viewers.

People in green jumpsuits walking up multiple pink and yellow staircases
Squid Game: The Challenge has faithfully recreated the show’s sets, including the staircases (Image via Netflix)

Their excitement is nervous energy as they play the children’s games from the show, because they know what happens if they fail: elimination. There’s an explosion on their chest. Dark liquid splatters onto their skin, dripping down, and oozes through their white t-shirts.

It is black, not dark red, this liquid. Don’t worry! this goo says. The players are not actually being murdered! It’s just simulated murder! Set to beautiful music! Nina Simone’s “I Want a Little Sugar In My Bowl” plays over one montage of players being exploded out of the game.

Some players look shocked, devastated to have lost their chance at $4.56 million, close to the largest prize in reality TV history (just shy of The X Factor $5 million) to one member of the largest cast in reality TV history.

Others dramatically still throw themselves to the ground as if they’d actually been shot with a gun. What fun!

Yes, Squid Game: The Challenge is the bleakest of reality TV competitions, inexplicably unaware of its source material’s themes and its own reproduction of them.

I found myself repulsed, bored, and captivated by its opening volley of five episodes. It will undoubtedly be a massive hit, for the thrill of watching people attempt these challenges and for adhering to reality TV competition conventions.

People in green jumpsuits run across sand toward a pink line; on the other side of the line is a large doll facing away
Players try to avoid being pretend-shot on Squid Games: The Challenge’s version of Red Light, Green Light (Image via Netflix)

The reality TV version, created by people who entirely missed what Squid Game was about, or just didn’t care, extracts the games, the sets, the costumes, and the music, and ignores the rest.

Squid Game: The Challenge is like someone watching Ina Garten stuff a turkey, and deciding that looks like so much fun they’ll just ram produce into a random bird’s anus. It misses the point.

Producers have and added their own material to fill even more episodes and screen time than the original series. In those 10 hours, they still don’t find time to develop an original idea, or acknowledge their complicity in creating its own kind of suffering..

The most explicit example comes immediately, in “Red Light, Green Light.” Squid Game: The Challenge’s producers are so dedicated to the reproduction of the game—and, remarkably and admirably, to making them fair competitions—that they ignored the suffering they caused.

For the first game, “Red Light, Green Light,” Squid Game: The Challenge tells us that the players had five minutes to cross its 100 meters, freezing in place at the command of a nearly 14-foot doll.

The game actually lasted five hours for some of them, and players had to stand, frozen, in literal freezing weather: reports say it was 0 degrees Celsius or colder during filming at the massive Cardington Studios, where players were for a full day. During the game, they stood for 20 or 30 minutes at a time, waiting to discover if they’d been eliminated, prohibited from moving.

The episode lies to us and conceals that, instead presenting a version that shows people running, crawling, and being splattered in the black goo when they fail to freeze or make the finish line.

Stephen Lambert, CEO of Studio Lambert (which co-produced the show with The Garden) delights in the mechanics of this scene. That would normally fascinate me, if this wasn’t so oblivious about the suffering it caused. In Netflix press materials, he explains:

“The reality was that we had a complex automated video system and a team of at least a dozen adjudicators that was picking out everybody that moved after the doll stopped singing. So we had a video record of every sector. Then we had a whole bunch of people scrutinizing these videos and identifying people that moved. And if they thought that people had moved, the video would then be shown to the Chief Adjudicator who would confirm that that was a movement that was outside the rules. For the players who got across the line quite quickly, the whole thing lasted about two hours, but for players who were slower, it was more like four or five hours. And obviously that was quite arduous, but everybody had been told it was going to be arduous.”

Netflix denied only that there was any “serious injury” from this arduousness. Yet players separately told Rolling Stone and Vice about various kinds of physical suffering they and others endured, and how they could not help players in distress for fear of being eliminated themselves. Some also claimed the game was “rigged,” citing, among other things, return flights had already been scheduled for after that game.

A player told The Sun, “Even if hypothermia kicked in then people were willing to stay for as long as possible because a lot of money was on the line. Too many were determined not to move so they stood there for far too long. There were people arriving thinking they were going to be millionaires but they left in tears.”

This is as depressing as it is provocative: Why do people subject themselves to the indignities associated with reality TV? Is it truly the allure of money or experience, as some of them claim? Are they, like their fictional counterparts, sunk by debt? Or are there other layers as to why they sign ludicrous contracts, leave jobs and families, to subject themselves to whatever the producers have in store, to whatever degree of dehumanization or incompetence they might find once on set?

And here we come to the show’s other problem: Squid Game: The Challenge has crafted its first five episodes in such a way that it is an actual challenge to know or care about any of the players.

People in green jumpsuits have tears in their eyes, and look up at something off-screen
Squid Game: The Challenge players in the fourth episode of Netflix’s reality TV adaptation of the scripted series (Image via Netflix)

As in Squid Game, the first game thins the crowd, but not to a manageable number.

For me to care about players in a game requires knowing them, what the stakes are for them. They are obviously not facing death, and the consequences for the players—besides losing a reality TV show—remains a mystery.

Squid Game: The Challenge attempts to find its way around this by cutting to an interview in which a player shares a quick anecdote. That does not count as character development. There is no curiosity about their motivations, just brief exposition.

The show does a bad job of translating the players’ emotional state to us. They are simply cogs in Netflix’s money-making reality TV machine, which is obvious yet somehow also escapes the show’s notice.

The players’ humanity is dulled even more by players referring to each other by number, and by the editing, which most often gives its attention to most people only right before someone is eliminated. Even a recognizable face—a Survivor alum, Figgy—floats up and away quickly.

The players do, at times, appear genuinely affected by this experience. Some cry or shake in fear; one gets nauseous. Others console each other. “We’re all gonna die,” one player says, and another declares, “I’m ready to die.”

Because this is happening to people we don’t know, it’s just laughable, not humanizing.

A large room with huge stacks of bunk beds on either side; at the end of the room is a large screen that shows 456
Squid Game: The Challenge starts with 456 players, but not all will stay in its dorm (Photo by Pete Dadds/Netflix)

Players live in a massive dorm room with towers of bunks, and eat scant food out of tins, as in Squid Game. No one is stabbed, at least not in the five episodes I have watched. But they do mob one person, clawing and stealing their food.

In between games, some gossip, some form friendships, one whispers a threat of post-game violence. No one intervenes.

When the games arrive, there’s even more contrast between this exercise and Squid Game, whose fictional players faced death if they did not figure out a game quickly enough.

The reality TV contestants know what games to expect from the six games featured in the series, and how to play them. (At least one new game has been expanded into a giant version, clever in design and true to the original spirit.)

Somehow, whether a game is unfolding or people are talking in the dormitory, the first few episodes proceed at a glacial pace.

Producers eventually find clever ways to liven things up and upend their expectations for these games, to pit them against each other for our entertainment. Sometimes a player is selected by producers or by each other for an opportunity, elimination, or mini-challenge. Eliminations happen from an all-player vote and from single players just picking a foe to eliminate.

By episode four, Squid Game: The Challenge veers so far into Survivor or Big Brother territory that its return to Squid Game is surprising. “This is a cruel, vicious, savage game,” one player says.

Another pleads, “Think about each other, don’t think about yourselves.” No one listens.

A close-up of hands on a small round metal tin, which has a brown cookie inside, with the outline of an umbrella; one hand is dragging a pin along the outline
Player 299 tries to carve an umbrella out of a cookie during Squid Games: The Challenge’s second episode (Image via Netflix)

Squid Game: The Challenge is not the first time Squid Game has been adapted into real-life games. Mr. Beast—the YouTuber who does nice things for people as long as he can film and then monetize his magnanimous acts of service—recreated the sets for 456 players and offered a prize of $456,000.

Netflix has upped the prize considerably, yet is worse than Mr. Beast, simply using people—and the IP of a show that was about capitalism, inequality, and economic desperation—to make themselves even more money.

I found one of the new games fascinating, and the twists momentarily tantalizing. Yet under the umbrella of Squid Game, I kept being reminded of how people were being used, twisted into a shape for us and then dumped into the recycling bin. Sure, they won’t have their organs harvested, though at least that might get the losers some cash.

In Squid Game, the games were watched only by wealthy gamblers who bet on players. Turning that game into real-life mass entertainment means that we are in their position, watching—though not being enriched.

Though Squid Game: The Challenge is being produced for our entertainment, we are the ones paying a massive corporation for the favor of distracting us for a few moments, especially from what its own source material was trying to say.

Squid Game: The Challenge

Spectacularly produced and spectacularly grim, this reality TV adaptation is an average reality TV competition at its rotten core. D

What works for me:

  • The production design
  • The new challenges

What could be better:

  • Developing players into characters
  • The slow pace and clunky editing
  • Having some awareness of Squid Game‘s story and themes

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, we may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

About the writer

Discussion: your turn

The writing here is the start of a conversation, and reality blurred values your contributions to that conversation. We’ve created a community that connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching, the pop culture we’re consuming, and the stories about it.

To share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space, there are rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to those rules.

Happy discussing!

JF

Sunday 26th of November 2023

I thoroughly enjoyed the first five episodes. I think there was more tension than I've seen on any reality show honestly. There's near constant anxiety about having to eliminate friends or them being eliminated by others. There are the Netflix requisite cliffhangers, which were perfectly timed. And of course, the sets, music, costumes, and every other detail were exact matches for the drama that served as inspiration. I do like that they added new games to keep the players (and us) guessing.

But, the most important thing they did that I hope you noticed Andy is this . . . they spent many confessional segments on contestants who would then be eliminated. Most shows give confessionals to winners and the eliminated contestant of the episode. This series has mixed that up so we can't count the confessionals and say, "Well, this person is getting focused on so they either win the challenge or get voted off." THAT is something every reality show needs to implement.

That difference also closely aligns with the drama. Although we were with the winner from the beginning of the drama, there were frequently background characters all of a sudden coming into the spotlight after others had faded due to death.

If I were to change anything, it would be the following:

* Don't harm contestants (and rectify any damages that did occur in S1). * Don't have episodes like #4 spent mostly in the dorm; always include a game. * Add some subplot intrigue like the drama by having a few characters have to explore the underbelly of the game. Maybe it's a second way to win? Maybe they have to discover the clues kind of like The Devil's Plan on Netflix (Andy check that one out if you haven't -- very different).

~ZZZ~

Monday 27th of November 2023

@JF, The Devil's Plan was really cool! I agree with your changes.

Bad Mitten

Saturday 25th of November 2023

I actually found this quite entertaining and thought the editing was very good for the amount of people that they had.

I certainly don’t support the show mistreating contestants and clearly there could have been some better planning as far as adjudicating red light green light, but I also think it would be a little dumb to assume you’re going into the squid games getting red carpet treatment.

Zim

Saturday 25th of November 2023

I was puzzled when watching red light green light at why some people would lay on the ground when they stopped and why the one contestant gave up when she stopped in a crouching position for what was shown as being seconds. Now it all makes sense.

~ZZZ~

Monday 27th of November 2023

@Zim, Right? We were like wtf, that girl can't half squat for 2 minutes? 🤣

Jan

Friday 24th of November 2023

I found the show to be pretty much what I expected it to be. No one made those people do the show, and for the amount of money they have a chance to win I wouldn't think they would make it to easy for them. I agree with most of this article, but I'm not going to take the show too serious. As of now, I will probably continue to watch it.

Keith

Thursday 23rd of November 2023

Prediction: Peacock/NBCUniversal/Lionsgate/SchenhardtWigCo will attempt a similarly clueless-to-the-real-meaning adaptation of the Hunger Games.