Skip to Content
reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000

Claim to Fame is returning! These 6 Jeopardy! champs will compete on Jeopardy! Masters!

Claim to Fame is returning! These 6 Jeopardy! champs will compete on Jeopardy! Masters!
Kevin Jonas and Frankie Jonas, hosts of Claim to Fame, which is now casting for season 2. (Photo by John Fleenor/ABC)

At the Television Critics Association winter press tour today, ABC announced the renewal of two of its game shows; a new “elite level iteration” spin-off of Jeopardy! called Jeopardy! Masters; and a season two of one of 2022’s best new reality series, Claim to Fame.

The renewed game shows are both revivals of classic shows:

  • Celebrity Family Feud season 9, hosted by Steve Harvey, as always
  • Press Your Luck season 5, hosted by Elizabeth Banks

While Match Game ended after five seasons, there are two other not-yet-renewed ABC game shows: The $100,000 Pyramid just finished a season in December, and The Chase just started the back half of its third season.

But ABC does have more Claim to Fame and Jeopardy! (with six all-star winners returning) on the way.

Claim to Fame season 2

Claim to Fame is casting for season 2. Will Kevin Jonas and Frankie Jonas return to host?
Claim to Fame is casting for season 2. Will Kevin Jonas and Frankie Jonas return to host? (Photo by John Fleenor/ABC)

Claim to Fame, my favorite new competition format of 2022, is returning for season two this year.

It began casting during season one, and ABC announced the renewal this morning, noting that it was the top “broadcast program in the Monday 10 p.m. hour last summer with Adults 18-49” last summer.

Kevin and Frankie Jonas will continue to host, though the cast of Claim to Fame season 2 was not yet announced.

ABC promises “double the fun, with super-sized competition, drama and more,” which may or may not mean double the budget, so that they can go someplace other than the pool deck.

That said, for an often hilariously, um, inexpensive series, it used its location and spaces well, and had some inventive challenges. I’m eager to see season two!

Jeopardy! Masters

Mattea Roach gestures with both palms face up, with the Jeopardy logo on a screen in the background
Jeopardy! champion Mattea Roach

Three years ago, Alex Trebek hosted the Jeopardy!: Greatest of All Time tournament, on which the three then-best Jeopardy! players—James Holzhauer, Ken Jennings, and Brad Rutter—faced off, with many categories featuring Disney ads.

Now, Jeopardy! host Ken Jennings will host a new tournament that features one of his old competitors.

Alex Trebek with Jeopardy: The Greatest of All Time contestants James Holzhauer, Ken Jennings, and Brad Rutter
Alex Trebek with Jeopardy: The Greatest of All Time contestants James Holzhauer, Ken Jennings, and Brad Rutter (Photo by Eric McCandless/ABC)

Jeopardy! Masters, ABC says, “will feature the six highest-ranked, current Jeopardy! contestants, who will face off in a Champions League style event to win the coveted title of Jeopardy! Masters Champion.”

ABC says there will be hour-long episodes with two games in each—and each episode will “showcase the six highest-ranked current Jeopardy! contestants, with two action-packed and high-stakes games.”

The network did not yet say how many episodes this will run, or when it will air. With six players total, all playing in each episode, that could make for 20 different combinations of three players, so 10 episodes—if my math is right!

The Jeopardy! Masters players

A woman in a pink dress behind a game show podium that displays $250,000 and Jeopardy! Champions
Amy Schneider after winning Jeopardy’s 2022 Tournament of Champions (Photo by Jeopardy!)

Here are the six players who will compete, along with their ABC bios.

Matt Amodio

Matt Amodio, whose 38-game winning streak spanned seasons 37 and 38, holds the No. 3 spots for both all-time consecutive games won and highest winnings in regular season play ($1,518,601). He is one of only four people to earn more than $1 million in their initial appearances on the show: two of them are fellow Masters competitors Amy Schneider and James Holzhauer; Masters host Ken Jennings is the third. The “Amodio Rodeo” resulted in some impressive stats for season 38: He had the most buzzes in a single game (43), most correct responses in a single game (42), the highest Double Jeopardy! round score ($48,400) and tied for the highest score in the “Jeopardy!” round ($18,600). Amodio also had the highest single-game winnings for that season: $83,000, the highest non-Holzhauer single-game score in “Jeopardy!” history. Even though Amodio fell short of the 2022 ToC finals, his total prize money to date is high enough for No. 5 on the all-time winnings list (including tournaments). Amodio is a postdoctoral researcher at the Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard after earning his PhD with a focus in machine learning and artificial intelligence at Yale. He currently lives in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

Sam Buttrey

Sam Buttrey dominated the field on his way to becoming the 2021 Professors Tournament champion: His average correct response score was a whopping 96.1%. He proved his mettle in the 2022 Tournament of Champions, winning his quarterfinal in a runaway and punching his ticket to the finals with an impressive semifinal performance wherein he boasted a 95% correct response rate and answered two Daily Doubles correctly. In the finals, he held his own against Amy Schneider and Andrew He, and claimed one crucial win in Game 5. Though he finished third, his performance in the tournament was one for the ages, rocketing him to the top tier of current players and becoming a fan favorite along the way. Buttrey is an associate professor of operations research at the Naval Postgraduate School in Pacific Grove, California. He bears an uncanny resemblance to Steve Martin and plays the keyboards in his spare time.

Andrew He

Andrew He is a season 38 five-day champion whose streak came to a premature end at the hands of Amy Schneider in her first win. His performance throughout his initial five games was impressive: He led all competitors that season with the largest correct Daily Double wager ($14,000) and tied for the highest score in the “Jeopardy!” round ($18,600). It was his performance in the 2022 Tournament of Champions, though, that really proved that he is an elite “Jeopardy!” player: He delivered jaw-dropping correct responses on huge wagers in the quarterfinals and semifinals; and in a rematch with Schneider in the finals, he beat her twice over the course of the six-game series. Though Schneider eventually beat him to that crucial third win, his second-place finish in that tournament cemented his legacy as one of the best players in the show’s history. He lives in San Francisco, California, where he works as a software developer. He is expecting his first child in 2023.

James Holzhauer

James Holzhauer is truly a “Jeopardy!” legend. A professional sports gambler from Las Vegas, he lit up the competition over the course of a 32-game streak in season 35 with his intensely competitive style of play and sky-high “all-in” wagers. He’s No. 4 on the all-time consecutive wins list, and he set the single-game winnings record with a $131,127 score; he also holds the next nine spots on the Top 10 list for single-game winnings. Holzhauer is one of only two contestants to earn more than $2 million in regular season play ($2,462,216); only Ken Jennings is ahead of him on that list, and Holzhauer nearly reached his total in less than half the number of games played. Holzhauer has returned to the “Jeopardy!” stage twice to date: He won the 2019 Tournament of Champions and finished in second place in 2020’s special primetime event “Jeopardy! The Greatest of All Time.” His total winnings of $2,962,216 puts him in third place on the all-time winnings list (including tournaments). Holzhauer and his wife, Melissa, are very active in philanthropy, particularly with Project 150, a local Las Vegas organization that provides resources to homeless and disadvantaged teens in Southern Nevada.

Mattea Roach

Mattea Roach, the first Gen Z super-champion, whose wide-ranging knowledge and unique personality made them a season 38 phenomenon, is the youngest contestant currently ranked in the Top 5 for all-time consecutive games won. Their 23 wins put them in the fifth spot on that list, and the $560,983 amassed during that streak places them at No. 6 for highest winnings in regular season play and No. 10 for all-time winnings (including tournaments). They put up impressive stats during their streak, with a 92% average for correct responses and 71.1% average buzzer score, a number that led the 2022 Tournament of Champions field going into the competition. Roach was a semifinalist in the ToC and defeated fellow Masters competitors Amy Schneider and Matt Amodio in the special exhibition game. Roach is a writer and podcaster living in Toronto, Canada. Since their appearance on “Jeopardy!,” they became the new host of “The Backbench,” a podcast that “digs into Canadian politics from the best seats in the House.”

Amy Schneider

Amy Schneider’s electrifying 40-game streak in season 38 landed her at No. 2 on the “Jeopardy!” all-time consecutive wins list; only 74-game champion (and “Jeopardy! Masters” host) Ken Jennings is ahead of her. She is one of only four people to earn more than $1 million in regular-season winnings, and her $1,382,800 puts her at No. 4 on that list. Schneider’s stats during her streak show her mastery of the game: Throughout all of season 38, she had the most buzzer attempts in a single game, ran the most total categories (28), and tied for running the most categories in a single game (three) and highest “Jeopardy!” round score ($18,600). Schneider returned to the “Jeopardy!” stage and won the 2022 Tournament of Champions, emerging victorious against the biggest and most competitive field of ToC contestants in the show’s history. With the $250,000 grand prize, Schneider’s all-time winnings (including tournaments) total $1,632,800: good for the No. 4 spot. Schneider, the first transgender “Jeopardy!” super-champion, was named one of PEOPLE Magazine’s Women Changing the World in 2022; she also visited the White House for Trans Day of Visibility that year. Her upcoming podcast, “Amy Always Wins,” will be produced by SmartLess Media and hosted by Rob Corddry. Schneider lives in Oakland, California, where she works as a writer, with her wife Genevieve and their cat, Meep.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More from reality blurred

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart

    Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how itโ€™s made and what it means.

Discussion: your turn

I think of writing about television as the start of a conversation, and I value your contributions to that conversation. We’ve created a community that connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

To share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space, I’ve created these rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to those rules.

Happy discussing!


Tuesday 9th of May 2023

On last night's Jeopardy! (05/08/23) one of the contestants was the sister of Omar from last season of Survivor, Juveria Zaheer. She correctly answered a question where the response was Fiji. :-D


Thursday 12th of January 2023

Ooh yay, more Jeopardy! I love Amy Schneider, hope she wins.