Skip to Content

On Survivor, ‘jackets and eggs’, plus an evacuation and an elimination

On Survivor, ‘jackets and eggs’, plus an evacuation and an elimination
Angelina Keeley and Lyrsa Torres on Survivor David vs. Goliath episode 5. (Photo Robert Voets/CBS Entertainment)

“Natalie, is there any way I could have your jacket?” Angelina asked Natalie. There was no response, except perhaps the laughter in places where people were watching Survivor David vs. Goliath, which is delivering entertainment on multiple levels this season.

“Natalie? Natalie?”

But Natalie was gone, and so was her jacket. So, too, was the character who’s received the most disproportionate and one-note edit, though Natalie was far from a true villain. Lyrsa said that “possibly, outside of the game, she’s an adorable lady. Inside the game, she’s not.”

As she left, Natalie demonstrated her multiple dimensions:

  • a capacity for self-awareness (“some of the things that were said were true”)
  • her surprising joy (“I was loving the game”—and she was, even during the cyclone!)
  • a tendency to miss what was happening right in front of her (explaining why she wouldn’t give her coat to Angelina, Natalie said, “I didn’t know she was part of the reason why I’m out,” even though it was immediately clear that Angelina was stunned by the vote)
Natalie Cole, Survivor David vs. Goliath

Natalie Cole laughs in the face of a cyclone on Survivor David vs. Goliath. (Photo by Robert Voets/CBS Entertainment)

And let’s not forget the part about demanding things of other people, from deciding to boil all the tribe’s eggs at once to telling the producer interviewing her that it was time to leave—which, you know, is just amazing.

“I am never the center of drama,” Natalie said, practically daring the editors to make her the center of drama for most of the season.

Yet even as a cyclone moved in and the contestants were evacuated, Natalie was enjoying the experience. I think she just gave all of her positive energy to the wrong parts (cyclones).

Natalie left the game because, for the second week in a row, a Goliath flipped—without telling their original tribemates. This time, it was Mike White, who’d said “I’m ready to have a little bit of Survivor without Natalie.”

At Tribal Council, which was funnier than entire seasons of Modern Family and didn’t even have to kill off a character to get people to watch again, the major topic of conversation was jackets.

That’s because Natalie asked/threatened/bullied Nick, asking him to leave behind his jacket and/or steal Lyrsa’s jacket. Natalie said this was “a negotiation” and that she “was leveraging” her power; Nick experienced it as “bullying.”

Angelina defended Natalie at Tribal, saying “she really prioritizes efficiency” and then basically taking the blame, saying Natalie was trying to get a jacket for Angelina, because she was cold all the time.

“I think that it came from love,” Angelina said, which was incredibly kind and/or the world’s most impressive stretch.

Angelina didn’t want to vote out Natalie because of the math, which she pointed out in an interview: Natalie’s exit means there’s now a 7-7 split between the original tribes, though they are presently in three different tribes, and the preview suggests more fractures.

I’d take that for typical Survivor misdirection, but this season the cast is not playing when it comes to discarding logic for comfort.

Survivors evacuate for a cyclone

A beautiful 17 seconds of sunlight and warmth was interrupted by a tropical system so severe that Survivor’s production team had time to write a note, print it on faux parchment, and then deliver it to each tribe as tree mail.

Tangent: I miss tree mail! Do they still get it and just ignore it?

The cast returned from their presumable sequester in a hotel (Did they seem freshly showered? Would they even be allowed to shower?) to find their camps in disarray and to find a person who snuck onto the show and whose name is Alison.

Tangent #2: Seriously, where was she the previous four episodes?

Also appearing for the first time this season: reward challenges! (I suppose the very first opening challenge counted as a reward challenge, but otherwise there have been combined reward/immunity challenges.)

Tangent #3: How did they not use the slingshot challenge for a David tribe vs. Goliath tribe challenge?

First prize was hens and a rooster, and second prize were just eggs. The orange tribe won that, and then won the immunity challenge, too, thanks to Elizabeth’s squirrel-huntin’ practice.

Meanwhile, Dan went idol hunting, and found a clue instead of an idol. It required him to stealthily retrieve the idol during the immunity challenge.

Dan kneeled down while watching others navigate the puzzles, and shoved it into his pants. It’s the only place he could put it, and since he was wearing what look like skin-tight bike shorts, the only place he could put it inconspicuously was in the front. (Remember that Survivor contestants don’t choose their own clothes; it seems like whoever dressed them this season discovered a new kind of underwear because several men are wearing the same style.)

But still: Wouldn’t someone look over during their boat ride back and notice that his bulge looked lumpy and misshapen?

Anyway, Dan now has two idols, and also has a reason to be proud of himself—and bring some drama and a few tears to an episode that was also part natural disaster thriller (howling winds, flooding shelters), part comedy (Natalie? Natalie?), and entirely, thoroughly enjoyable.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More great stories

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means.


I value our community at reality blurred, which connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

Comment rules: My goal is for us to be able to share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space. That’s why I’ve created these rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to them.

Happy discussing!