Skip to Content
reality TV reviews, news, and analysis since 2000

Which is more important: reality show hosts or formats?

Which is more important: reality show hosts or formats?
Zac Posen, Heidi Klum, Tim Gunn, and Nina Garcia backstage at the Project Runway season 13 finale. (Photo by Barbara Nitke/Lifetime)

The news that Tim Gunn and Heidi Klum have left Project Runway made me fear for the future of Project Runway, which was on the verge of being reinvigorated by returning to Bravo and returning to the safe hands of Magical Elves, the production company that created the show.

That also reminded me that Mary Berry, Mel, and Sue exiting The Great British Bake-Off made me declare—not at all hyperbolically!—that her departure was “the worst-case scenario” and one that “effectively ends” GBBO. Oh, and I also wrote that the show’s producers and new network were “delusional.”

But I just started watching season eight of Bake-Off, which Netflix acquired from Channel 4, and it’s still pretty great.

So I was the one who was delusional about the resiliency of the format, which includes everything from the tent to the show’s tone, the structure of the competition to the way it’s cast.

GBBO series 7, Paul Hollywood, Sandi Toksvig, Noel Fielding, Prue Leith

The new Great British Baking Show cast: judge Paul Hollywood, hosts Sandi Toksvig and Noel Fielding, and judge Prue Leith.

I do miss Mary, but Prue Leith is terrific, and so is host Sandi Toksvig’s dry wit, which had me laughing right away in episode one.

I’m warming to Noel Fielding, whose humor is farther outside the show’s box, so it’s a bit more jarring. And it helps that Sandi’s voice is similar enough to Sue’s, and Prue’s voice is similar enough to Mary’s, to feel comfortable instead of alien.

Is it possible that hosts and the central characters matter less?

Does continuity (i.e. Paul Hollywood, or perhaps Nina Garcia continuing with Runway) soften the blow of those kinds of transitions?

I explored these questions, and some examples from the past, in a story for Vulture: Do Reality Competitions Need Big-Name Hosts?

I think the answer might ultimately be “it depends,” but it was interesting to think about what departures worked (100 percent of America’s Got Talent’s judges and hosts have changed over its life) and which definitely did not (America’s Next Top Model).

So I considered the multiple factors involved. For example, as I wrote:

“Does a show just need to keep one or more consistent cast members in order to not fall apart? Housewives come and go on the Real Housewives franchise, but it’s never a complete changeover, so there’s discomfort wrapped in the familiar blanket of rich people sniping at each other. Once a format becomes familiar or beloved to viewers, it’s much less unsettling for there to be cast changes.

Yet doing that didn’t work for CBS’s Baking Competition, which had Paul Hollywood as one of its judges, because CBS also Americanized GBBO’s format instead of embracing the original.”

Read the full piece at Vulture.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More from reality blurred

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart

    Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means.

Discussion: your turn

I think of writing about television as the start of a conversation, and I value your contributions to that conversation. We’ve created a community that connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

To share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space, I’ve created these rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to those rules.

Happy discussing!