Skip to Content

The 17 most-popular reality blurred stories of 2017

The 17 most-popular reality blurred stories of 2017

In 2017, a reality show star became the president of the United States, and the presidency and politics certainly dominated headlines. And although reality television itself didn’t break through to the national conversation in the way it has in the past, there was excellent reality television this year—and a lot to talk about, debate, discuss, ponder, question, and celebrate.

On reality blurred, almost six million stories were read this year, and I’ve gathered together those that were most-frequently read—by regular readers like you, fans who shared stories on social media, or people who were in search of information and turned to Google while watching TV.

Enjoy this look back at the year during these waning days of 2017, and here’s to a happy 2018 for you and those you know and love. Thanks for all of your support this year, and I’ll see you next year.

Happy New Year!


17. A lament about Project Runway’s twins, who won Twinning

Claire Buitendorp, Shawn Buitendorp, Project Runway 16, unconventional materials recycling center

Claire Buitendorp and Shawn Buitendorp absolutely dominated most of Project Runway‘s 16th season—though not, alas, because of their talent or clothes.


16. Why Matt Paxton is leaving Hoarders, which is again on the bubble

Hoarders, Matt Paxton, Dr. Robin Zasio

Extreme cleaning specialist Matt Paxton left Hoarders early last year, concluding with an episode that he told me was “The most difficult hoard I’ve ever seen in my entire life.”


15. A few of Hunted’s absurd rules have been revealed

Hunted hunters clothes

CBS tried to introduce a new format this year, but frustratingly concealed the details from viewers, leading to intense interest in the show’s rules. We learned some of them from two of its cast members, and I also learned more about how it was produced by fact-checking a scene from the show.


14. How Siesta Key was filmed and how it differs from Laguna Beach

MTV Siesta Key, cast

Next year, MTV is bringing back Jersey Shore‘s cast, but this year, they brought back the Jersey Shore format for a truly ugly series. Before that, they resurrected the format pioneered on Laguna Beach, which made reality TV look more like a drama than a documentary. I talked to the new show’s producers about how they produced it—and how Siesta Key differed from its predecessor.


13. Why I stopped watching Big Brother 19

Paul Abrahamian, BB19

Those who stuck around to see the end of Big Brother season 19 eventually saw Paul Abrahamian lose the game again, but I gave up long before that. Even second place was too good, consider Paul was wrapped in advantage after advantage by BB19, whose producers don’t seem interested in letting a game play out without tilting the playing field heavily in favor of someone they imagine is a fan favorite.


12. Survivor Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers: season 35’s cast, twist, and more

Jeff Probst, Survivor Game Changers

There’s always interest in new and upcoming seasons of Survivor, even when they eventually turn out to be mostly duds. Oh, I kid Survivor season 35—it was only 80 percent a dud.


11. Why isn’t Yolanda McClary back on Cold Justice?

Cold Justice, Yolanda McClary, Kelly Siegler

Cold Justice was revived by Oxygen, which rebranded in 2017 to become a network focused on true crime. But one of its cast members, Yolanda McClary, didn’t return.


10. Shark Tank made a few subtle but terrific changes this season

Shark Tank episode 905

New chairs! A new set! New guest sharks! A new seating chart! Shark Tank was tweaked significantly for its ninth season, and made changes that I really appreciated.


7, 8, and 9. The spring, summer, and fall reality TV show schedules

Summer 2017 reality TV schedule and guide

Three of my quarterly updates that  list reality show debuts basically tied for 7th place: spring, summer, and fall. Although I publish these four times a year, I update them constantly, usually several times a week, because new shows are added and networks often change their plans.


6. The Curse of Oak Island: Marty and Rick on skepticism and what they’d change

The Curse of Oak Island, Rick Lagina, Marty Lagina

I interviewed the stars of History Channel’s The Curse of Oak Island, another series that follows an ongoing search for treasure and has become the network’s most-popular series.


5. Survivor Gabon’s Dan Kay has died

Dan Kay, Survivor Gabon

Survivor cast member Dan Kay, who was just 40 years old and had two young kids, died on New Year’s Eve last year.

While the cause of death wasn’t public, that didn’t stop E! News from sensationalizing his death and the deaths of other Survivor cast members.


4. Amazing Race 30 started today with famous-ish teams

Phil Keoghan, Amazing Race 29, Tanzania pit stop

The Amazing Race has reached its milestone 30th season, which will start airing early in the new year. Its cast includes not just another CBS reality show crossover couple, but people who are involved in competitive pursuits and are well-known-ish.


3. Big Brother 2’s Kent Blackwelder has died

Kent Blackwelder, Bill 'Bunky' Miller, Big Brother 2, BB2

CBS’ version of Big Brother lost its first cast member this week, as BB2 houseguest Kent Blackwelder died last Saturday.


2. Why Shark Tank was dedicated to Iain Anderson’s memory

Iain Anderson, Shark Tank

An early Shark Tank season nine episode was dedicated to a person most viewers hadn’t ever heard of before: Iain Anderson, the show’s accountant, who’d recently died.


1. The Last Alaskans is returning, but without one family

The Last Alaskans, Ray Lewis, Cindy Lewis, family

The serene, meditative, beautifully shot series The Last Alaskans returned for a third season this year, but there was one major change that sent a lot of people to Google during the show: Where were Ray Lewis, Cindy Lewis, and their daughters?

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More great stories

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means. Learn more about Andy.


I value our community at reality blurred, which connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

Comment rules: My goal is for us to be able to share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space. That’s why I’ve created these rules for commenting here, and by commenting, you agree that you’ve read and agree to them. Happy discussing!