• reality shows
  • reality TV reviews
  • about
  • contact
  • reality TV schedule
  • best reality TV
  • send tips or feedback
  • support
  • subscribe
Top Chef 14

How Top Chef Charleston recovered from its episode-one screw-up

Top Chef 14, Sheldon Simeon, Brooke Williamson, Shirley Chung
Sheldon Simeon, Brooke Williamson, and Shirley Chung on Top Chef 14's penultimate episode. (Photo by Paul Cheney/Bravo)

by Andy Dehnart 2 Mar. 2017 | 8:00 pm

I cannot quite imagine a better final three for this all-star-ish season of Top Chef than the three who competed during last week’s episode. They are just the best: great cooks and competitors who share respect for each other and also a burning desire to win. This time.

Shirley, Brooke, and Sheldon were all so close to the title during their first seasons, which is part of what makes Sheldon’s loss last episode so tragic. To lose at the exact same stage of the competition again! And for such a simple error as cooking fish on a surface that wasn’t hot enough! Alas. But the great part is that they’d all be wonderful winners, and as Sheldon said repeatedly, they’re cooking against the best.

It’s a nice second chance for all three.

This season was a second chance for only half its cast, though. Remember the new chefs? The ones who were pretty much decimated? Their experience in the kitchen wasn’t enough to compare to their opponents’ experience in Top Chef’s soundstage kitchen. Never underestimate the power of knowing how things work, what they feel like, what to expect. In retrospect, it was a mistake to cast this competition that way.

Not all of the new chefs were total wrecks, of course—Sylva made the final five, and should have been in the final four—and some of the returning chefs were disasters.

In fourth place was John, who kept sliding through, barely, kept insisting he was a new person while showing us the opposite, mostly. His season-long conflict with Katsuji was a highlight and a lowlight, culminating in that delicious decision to pair them together as sous chef and angry chef. I’d watch a show where they cooked together while hurling insults and occasionally kitchen appliances.

Top Chef finally did history right

A cast of mostly unprepared chefs versus at-ease returnees made for an awkward and weak beginning, but that wasn’t season 14’s only problem.

It began by completely botching a visit to a plantation in episode one, using it as a backdrop after paying lip service to the pain and suffering that had been endured. But Top Chef Charleston didn’t repeat that mistake. Five episodes later, it offered a wonderful episode set at a different plantation. It was what they should have done in episode one—or really, episode one should not have been done at all. (To host a sudden death elimination there was just a bad choice in a series of bad choices.)

In episode six, the elimination challenge was held at a plantation, and it was the opposite of that first episode. The chefs cooked at Middleton Place, named after the Middleton family, who owned more than 2,800 slaves over a 130 year period. But Middleton Place wasn’t backdrop. While the show did not give as much attention to the place’s pre-Civil War history as I would have liked, especially after how dismissive it was in episode one, it did connect to that past.

The chef’s task was to pay homage to Edna Lewis, a chef whose influence on Southern cooking is still felt, even though her name isn’t well-known outside of chef circles—or even to some chefs. Born in 1916, she was the descendant of slaves who rose to prominence thanks to her cooking and cookbooks. During part of her career, she was the resident chef at Middleton Place, and cooked in the same kitchen the contestants used. (If you want to know more about her, read this in-depth profile: Edna Lewis and the Black Roots of American Cooking.)

The guests for the meal the chefs served were southern chefs who were influenced by Edna, including Art Smith, Toni Tipton Martin, and Alexander Smalls.

Not all of the chefs knew who Edna was, and that included Sylva, who illustrated the long and painful history of black people and cooking—which originated, of course, in slavery—by talking about how it caused a rift between him and his father. “Back in high school, I won a scholarship to go to CIA, but my father, he literally said, ‘No son of mine will be a domestic,” Sylva said in an interview.

Sylva told his fellow chefs, “It’s truly inspiring just because there’s very little black chefs we look up to, but the older generation—you know, like, people that’s my father’s age—we as black people were like domestics and servers and the help.”

In an interview, Sylva said, “Just growing up in New York, we’re surrounded by great cuisine and great restaurants. But inside those high-end cuisines there’s very little black chefs, let alone executive chefs. Not only was Edna a black chef, she was a black woman chef way back when, and she became an owner of a restaurant. Just learning about that drive and that passion—she didn’t stop, so why should I?”

Top Chef also inspired its viewers to learn more about Edna and cook like her—or at least, to buy her cookbook, The Taste of Country Cooking. The Friday after the show aired, that book “shot up to number 5 on the Amazon cookbook bestseller list, and number 11 on its overall bestseller list,” The Washington Post reported.

It’s still #1 in Amazon’s Southern cooking category. That’s meaningful impact—and I don’t mean the book sales alone. Top Chef thoughtfully presented information about a culinary icon, touched on American history, and connected it to a contestant’s life experiences in the midst of an ultimately trivial cooking competition, and inspired its viewers along the way. Bravo.

discuss this story

more great reality blurred stories

  • The 20 Survivor winners who will compete on Survivor season 40
  • How Antiques Roadshow works
  • Scare Tactics: The surprising way the show was cast
  • Behind the scenes of the Guy’s Grocery Games grocery store
  • The Survivor rule book and Survivor cast contract
  • How Big Brother’s house is designed

Reality TV in your inbox

Hand-crafted reality TV news and recommendations sent most Fridays. Unsubscribe any time!

most-popular stories on reality blurred

Boston Rob Mariano and Sandra Diaz-Twine on Survivor: Island of the Idols

Survivor 40's cast of 20 Survivor winners

Survivor season 40's all-winner cast has been revealed. Original winner Richard Hatch is not competing, but nearly every winner from seasons 22 to 37 is returning.

On Kings of Pain, Rob “Caveman” Alleva puts a tarantula hawk, a massive wasp, on Adam Thorn so it can sting him

Is Kings of Pain science or stupidity? An interview with a History Channel executive

An interview with a History Channel executive about Kings of Pain, on which two men are bitten and stung to see how much it hurts.

The central cast of MTV's Ex On the Beach: Peak of Love

Ex on the Beach: Peak of Love cast includes Adore Delano and Temptation Island singles

MTV announced the cast and air date for Ex On the Beach season 4, which has relocated to the mountains of New Zealand and now has the nonsensical name of Ex On the Beach: Peak of Love.

Andrea and Lamar, one of the couples featured on Love After Lockup: Life After Lockup season 2.

Life After Lockup season 2's cast and premiere date

Love After Lockup: Life After Lockup season 2's seven couples and premiere date have been announced by WE tv.

Jeff Probst on the premiere of Survivor Island of the Idols, standing next to a sign that reminds everyone what Survivor used to focus on.

Survivor season 40 will start earlier than usual

Survivor: Winners at War will premiere in February, and have a two-hour premiere.

A New Hampshire bridge in winter, which will take us from fall to spring reality TV shows

Winter 2020 reality TV schedule and guide

This winter reality show 2019 and 2020 schedule is a frequently updated list of premieres for broadcast, cable, and streaming reality TV shows, documentary series, game shows, and other prime-time nonfiction TV.

Survivor: 19 seasons, at least 19 naked cast members

From the site that brought us shirtless American Idol contestants and naked Real World cast members comes "A (Not So) Complete History of Naked 'Survivor' Castaways." In honor of Survivor's anniversary, YuppiePunk asks, "how better to look back on its history than how it began -- in the nude"? That history starts ...

Dr. Ish Major and Dr. V, aka Venus Nicolino, on Marriage Boot Camp: Reality Stars season 10. They're returning for season 13.

Marriage Boot Camp: Family Edition's new cast, and a preview of the season

WE tv's Marriage Boot Camp: Reality Stars season 13 is coming this fall. Watch the trailer and learn which "four famously dysfunctional families" have been cast.

Padma Lakshmi and Tom Colicchio during the Top Chef: Kentucky finale

Top Chef season 17: all stars are filming now

Former Top Chef contestants have been spotted at filming locations in the Los Angeles area, and the Restaurant Wars episode will be filmed next week.

Fall things: pumpkins, leaves, hay, waning light, and new seasons of your favorite reality shows

Fall 2019 reality TV schedule and guide

This fall reality show 2019 schedule is a frequently updated list of premieres for broadcast, cable, and streaming reality TV shows, documentary series, game shows, and other prime-time nonfiction TV.

behind the scenes of reality TV

Hoarders Randyland

Behind the scenes of Hoarders: Randyland

How Hoarders was filmed, from behind the scenes of a show that usually doesn’t allow visitors. Plus: What happened that wasn’t shown on TV on the season 4 episode “Randy/Vicki.”

American Grit season two, cadre member Riki Long, contestants Herman and Shermon

Behind the scenes of American Grit season two

John Cena’s reality show left the Pacific Northwest for the swamps outside of Savannah, Georgia, for season two.

Big Brother 20, BB20

Big Brother cast contract: the agreement houseguests sign

This is the Big Brother contract, which cast members sign during casting. It details things like houseguests’ pay and prohibited behavior.

older

The problems with Top Chef Charleston’s visit to a plantation

other recaps more stories about Top Chef 14

discuss this story

about Andy Dehnart

Andy Dehnart’s writing and criticism about television, culture, and media has appeared on NPR and in Vulture, Pacific Standard, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications. He has covered reality television for more than 18 years, and created reality blurred in 2000.

A member of the Television Critics Association who serves on its board of directors, Andy, 41, also directs the journalism program at Stetson University in Florida, where he teaches creative nonfiction and journalism. He has an M.F.A. in nonfiction writing and literature from Bennington College. Learn more about reality blurred and Andy.

stay connected with reality TV

Get advice about what to watch and keep up with the latest in reality television with reality blurred's e-mail newsletter. Just enter your e-mail address:

about reality blurred

reality blurred is your guide to the world of reality TV and unscripted entertainment, with reality show reviews, news, and analysis. It was created in 2000 by Andy Dehnart. He's still writing and publishing it today.

reality blurred is regularly updated with highlights from the world of reality TV: news and analysis; behind-the-scenes reports; interviews with reality TV show cast members and producers; and recaps and reviews of these reality TV shows, including Survivor, Big Brother, The Great British Baking Show, Shark Tank, The Amazing Race, The Bachelor, Project Runway, Dancing with the Stars, Top Chef, and many more.

explore

  • recent news
  • reviews of reality TV shows
  • behind the scenes reports
  • interviews with producers and reality stars
  • archives
  • send tips
  • search
  • advertise on reality blurred
  • about reality blurred
  • newsletter
  • RSS and social media
  • contact reality blurred
  • send tips & contribute
  • privacy policy
  • terms of service
Copyright © 2000 to 2019 Andy Dehnart and individual contributors.