• reality shows
  • reality TV reviews
  • about
  • contact
  • reality TV schedule
  • best reality TV
  • send tips or feedback
  • support
  • subscribe
Masterchef

Who should replace Joe Bastianich on MasterChef?

MasterChef judge Joe Bastianich
Departing MasterChef judge Joe Bastianich (Photo by Justin Stephens/FOX)

by Andy Dehnart 2 Dec. 2014 | 8:58 am

Before Thanksgiving, MasterChef judge Joe Bastianich announced he’s leaving the series after five seasons and three seasons of MasterChef Junior. (The third MasterChef Junior, which has already been filmed, debuts in early January.)

His departure seems very amicable, at least according to everyone’s official statements. Joe said he’d spent “several gratifying years” and that it was “a pleasure working alongside Gordon and Graham,” but said “I have decided to step down from my role on the show.” Fox and the show’s producers said in a joint statement that he “has played an integral role in the success of both MasterChef and MasterChef Junior, and we all appreciate his incredible culinary insight, sense of humor and passion.”

Before MasterChef Junior, on which Joe can be warm and even funny, I might have said that MasterChef didn’t need him at all, because he’s often so flat and grumpy. There often didn’t seem to be much reason for him to be there.

Several reports say producers are now casting for a new third judge. Swapping out judges is a tricky proposition; American Idol has stumbled a lot while The Voice has perfected it. It needs to be someone who brings something new but also fits in.

So who should join Graham and Gordon? I have a few ideas, and I’m sure there are many others who didn’t immediately come to mind:

  • Cat Cora. She needs a show worthy of her talent, and this could be it. While she doesn’t strike me as someone who might particularly want or need a full-time reality TV gig, she also keeps popping up on less-worthy shows. She co-hosted Bravo’s Around the World in 80 Plates; mentored a team on Food Network’s weak clone of The Taste, America’s Best Cook; and has made guest appearances such as on NBC’s awful Food Fighters. She also made a guest appearance on season one of MasterChef. If the show wants to cast another no-nonsense, tough but fair, and talented chef, look no further than Cat.
  • Giada De Laurentiis. She’s somewhat the opposite of Cat Cora as a television personality, so if the network or producers want to warm up the judging, Giada would be perfect. She’s particularly fantastic on Next Food Network Star, which is thematically similar to this series.
  • Alton Brown. He’s super-smart, great on camera, and really deserves better than Cutthroat Kitchen. And I’d like to see him spar with Gordon Ramsay, should they ever disagree on a dish or decision.
  • Ching-He Huang. She may not (yet) be a familiar name or face, but on her Cooking Channel show Restaurant Redemption, she’s basically who Gordon Ramsay used to be before he sold out: a talented chef who was tough but genuinely seemed to care about helping other chefs and restaurants improve. On her makeover series, she’s thoughtful and tough, and before it, did several cooking shows in the UK. Since the network went with relative unknowns for two of the three judges and that worked, they should try again.
  • Guy Fieri and Curtis Stone. This is a joke; I just wanted to make sure you were paying attention. Also, Fox and producers, please, please, don’t do this to me.
  • No one. I think this is a strong option. There isn’t really any need to have three judges, and often, the editors cut out the individual dish critiques of one or more of the judges, meaning there isn’t even enough time for there judges.

discuss this story

more great reality blurred stories

  • Recommended reality TV: Tidying Up with Marie Kondo and America to Me
  • The best reality TV shows of 2018
  • The Survivor rule book and Survivor cast contract
  • Go behind-the-scenes at the Big Brother house
  • Behind the scenes of The Last Alaskans
  • Interviews with reality TV producers and cast members

most-popular stories on reality blurred

Hunted, Emiley Cox, David Windecher

A few of Hunted’s absurd rules have been revealed

Hunted team David and Emiley revealed several of the show's rules on a radio show this morning—including one ridiculous rule that benefits the production.

Life Below Zero season 11, Sue Aikens

When Life Below Zero will return for season 11, and who it will follow

Exclusive: Life Below Zero is returning to National Geographic for season 11 this fall, with a cast that includes one new person.

Marriage Boot Camp: Hip Hop Edition

The cast of Marriage Boot Camp: Hip Hop Edition, and a preview of the season

Marriage Boot Camp season 14 is changing things up: instead of casting reality TV stars, the show has cast hip hop stars who've appeared on reality TV shows.

Iain Anderson, Shark Tank

Why Shark Tank was dedicated to Iain Anderson’s memory

Shark Tank season nine's third episode, number 906, ended with a title card that said, "In loving memory of Iain Anderson." Iain was the show's accountant, and he died Sept. 10 from mesothelioma.

Kunal Nayyar, Mayim Bialik, Method Man, Drop the Mic

How Drop the Mic’s celebrity rap battles are written

The new TBS series Drop the Mic features rap battles between celebrities, and one of its writers detailed how those are scripted by the show's writers.

Jeff Probst, Survivor David vs. Goliath episode 10

Survivor Edge of Extinction: What we know so far about Survivor season 38

Survivor season 38 will feature returning players and a huge twist that could effect how the game is played and who wins.

Salim, Gurki, Dating Around

Netflix’s Dating Around has romance, clever editing, and more than just straight white guys

One person has five first dates on Dating Around, which gives us multiple episodes with queer people of color dating other queer people of color. That shouldn't be remarkable, but it is.

Winter 2019 reality TV show debut schedule and guide

Winter 2019 reality TV schedule and guide

This winter reality show 2019 schedule is a frequently updated list of premieres for broadcast, cable, and streaming reality TV shows, documentary series, game shows, and other prime-time nonfiction TV.

Hoarders, Matt Paxton, Dr. Robin Zasio

Why Matt Paxton is leaving Hoarders, which is again on the bubble

Hoarders airs its season, maybe series, finale on Sunday, with what will be Matt Paxton's final episode. Why it's "the most difficult hoard I've ever seen."

Johnathan Hillstrand, Deadliest Catch

Why Deadliest Catch’s Johnathan Hillstrand didn’t actually retire

Johnathan Hillstrand has been actively crab fishing this season, but the Time Bandit isn't on Deadliest Catch season 14.

behind the scenes of reality TV

Behind the scenes of Knife Fight

What happens when a real restaurant becomes the set of a reality TV cooking competition.

American Grit season two, cadre member Riki Long, contestants Herman and Shermon

Behind the scenes of American Grit season two

John Cena’s reality show left the Pacific Northwest for the swamps outside of Savannah, Georgia, for season two.

Michael Johnson, Daytona Beach, American Ninja Warrior

Behind the Scenes of American Ninja Warrior

Behind-the-scenes details about American Ninja Warrior’s city qualifiers and city finals production: How it’s filmed, how locations are chosen, and more.

older

Yes, MasterChef Junior is even more awesome this season

newer >

MasterChef gets a new judge, another MasterChef Junior

more stories about Masterchef

reality TV news and reviews, in your inbox

One hand-crafted message sent every Friday. Free. Subscribe now:

discuss this story

about Andy Dehnart

Andy Dehnart’s writing and criticism about television, culture, and media has appeared on NPR and in Vulture, Pacific Standard, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications. He has covered reality television for more than 18 years, and created reality blurred in 2000.

A member of the Television Critics Association who serves on its board of directors, Andy, 41, also directs the journalism program at Stetson University in Florida, where he teaches creative nonfiction and journalism. He has an M.F.A. in nonfiction writing and literature from Bennington College. Learn more about reality blurred and Andy.

stay connected with reality TV

Get advice about what to watch and keep up with the latest in reality television with reality blurred's e-mail newsletter. Just enter your e-mail address:

about reality blurred

reality blurred is your guide to the world of reality TV and unscripted entertainment, with reality show reviews, news, and analysis. It was created in 2000 by Andy Dehnart. He's still writing and publishing it today.

reality blurred is regularly updated with highlights from the world of reality TV: news and analysis; behind-the-scenes reports; interviews with reality TV show cast members and producers; and recaps and reviews of these reality TV shows, including Survivor, Big Brother, The Great British Baking Show, Shark Tank, The Amazing Race, The Bachelor, Project Runway, Dancing with the Stars, Top Chef, and many more.

explore

  • recent news
  • reviews of reality TV shows
  • behind the scenes reports
  • interviews with producers and reality stars
  • archives
  • send tips
  • search
  • advertise on reality blurred
  • about reality blurred
  • newsletter
  • RSS and social media
  • contact reality blurred
  • send tips & contribute
  • privacy policy
  • terms of service
Copyright © 2000 to 2019 Andy Dehnart and individual contributors.