Skip to Content

What Wizard Wars, the best magic reality show, should change for season two

What Wizard Wars, the best magic reality show, should change for season two
Wizard Wars judges Christen Gerhart, Penn, and Teller (Photo by Dale Berman/Syfy)

On Friday, Syfy announced it had ordered six more episodes of its competition series Wizard Wars, which will debut in January. I’d prefer it to be more than just six episodes, because the show is one of the network’s best reality series and I miss it already. It’s definitely the best of the small wave of recent magic-themed reality shows.

The CW’s Penn and Teller: Fool Us is simply a three-year-old show from the UK being rebroadcast in the US. The magic is decent, but the show is frustrating. The whole conceit is that Penn and Teller try to figure out how the trick is done, but they don’t actually share the critical information with the audience. That makes sense, but even when the performance is really strong, it means the show has a weird letdown at the end of every act because we have no idea why it had that outcome.

Another CW series, Masters of Illusion, is a 14-year-old series that has outlived both networks that it was previously broadcast on: PAX and MyNetworkTV (which brought it back in 2009).  The CW created new episodes that are hosted by Dean Cain, but it felt like the show could have been repeats, since it comes across as stitched-together acts of varying quality. There’s something to be said for its straightforward and simple approach–just magic act after magic act–but it was less reality TV and instead just a broadcast of performances.

Wizard Wars finds the right formula

Syfy’s Wizard Wars attempts something new, which is only part of why it succeeds. While the conceit seemed to be borrowing from Chopped‘s playbook–give talented people random, unexpected things and expect them to use them in a refined way–the mystery basket seems like the easy part compared to creating a brand-new routine with a partner they’ve never performed with before. That seems like a challenge, and forcing the magicians to work together has produced some astounding magic and entertaining performances.

The best performances lock in to the low-rent vibe and the magicians are casual but sophisticated with their magic, creating not just tricks but also stories. After two pairs of challengers compete, the winner faces off against two of the house magicians with a whole new set of things. That gives us the chance to see the best act try to one-up themselves–and their competitors, who have a clear house advantage.

The show is well-paced, and it’s mini-bracketed competition works well. I don’t find the behind-the-scenes workshop footage to be all that compelling, but otherwise the show uses its time well: Penn & Teller and the other magicians/judges perform brief and impressive acts in-between the big four performances, and there’s just enough time allotted to judging. Host Ellen Fox does exactly what she needs to.

Overall, it’s a fun hour, though there are things I’d change besides adding even more episodes. After the season ended, I saw the Wizard Wars pilot, which you can watch below, and it surprised me because a lot of what I wanted from the series is right there.

The show was born in an 11-minute pilot posted to YouTube two years ago; it’s extremely well-made for something shot in an apartment’s living room (an excellent model for those with dreams of turning their YouTube videos into television shows), and you can see how it got the attention of A. Smith and Co. Productions.The strength of the format is clear, since a considerable amount of it survived to the Syfy version. Its host and co-creator, Justin Flom, is now one of the house magicians–er, wizards–while the other co-creator, Rick Lax, performs in the pilot and is now an executive producer.

What they created works well, and I hope they bring back some of it–and add other things. Here’s what I’d change for season two:

  • Tell us how much time the magicians get. The show is not transparent about how much time the magicians have to create their acts, but it’s more than the few minutes the editing suggests, because the acts often involve specially constructed props. Whether they have two hours or two days, say that. Here’s the thing: telling us they had time to prep doesn’t make their work any less impressive. The pilot episode gave its competitors one hour, but they weren’t doing bigger stage magic. Trying to suggest the magicians created an impressive routine in minutes doesn’t give them the credit they deserve for the work they’ve done.
  • Cut backstage time. The show could discard or at least shorten their backstage preparation, because it never reveals anything of substance, though it usually gives the magicians a brief chance to show off slight of hand or another skill. The pilot revealed a lot more about how the tricks were done, which makes that time justifiable, especially because it’s impressive to watch a performer screw up a rehearsal and then do a trick flawlessly later. Either show more or less.
  • The judges need to be more critical. I’m a naive idiot, yet on several occasions throughout the first season, it’d be obvious to me how a trick was done. And then the judges–magician Jason Latimer, magic critic Christen Gerhart, and Penn & Teller–would be impressed by that trick, and I’d roll my eyes. Perhaps they were more impressive in person, and the judges did occasionally point out that there were “flashes,” i.e. reveals, but I think the judges were just being generous and nice way too often. Also, during more than one episode, they basically made it sound like the two competing acts were equivalent even when it seemed pretty lopsided.
  • Use numeric scoring. One way to improve the judging is to borrow from the pilot, which shows the judges adding up points. They should do that now, perhaps with Dancing with the Stars-style paddles, or just by awarding points like Top Chef Masters once did. That would make the competition clearer and have one very positive side effect: letting us know exactly how Teller evaluated an act. Because he doesn’t speak on camera (though he does speak!), all of his feedback comes via Penn, and I’d rather see how he individually scored the magicians.
  • Give the winning team a prize. The team that wins the first round should win $10,000, and the prize for beating the pros should be higher, especially since the pros weren’t easy to beat. (Though, I disagreed with the judges several times.) A show never seems more like it’s produced on a budget than when there’s no prize for a team that’s really earned it.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More great stories

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means.


I value our community at reality blurred, which connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

Comment rules: My goal is for us to be able to share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space. That’s why I’ve created these rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to them.

Happy discussing!