Skip to Content

Big Brother didn’t become Survivor, it became more of Big Brother

Any fear/hope that Big Brother was turning into and/or borrowing from Survivor‘s game was put to rest during last night’s episode. While the cast is the best the show has had in years and minor production changes have improved the episodes, it remains Big Brother, for better or for worse. But as of right not, it’s definitely better, especially compared to the last few dreadful seasons.

The two HOH thing simply adds another step in the game; everything else remains exactly the same as always. I suppose there’s potential for the losing HOH’s nominations to come back and bite him or her, so perhaps it’ll yield dramatic dividends, but it did not this week.

Thus, all of the speculation about how this new game would unfold based on the little bit of information CBS revealed before the season started turned out to be wrong but oddly prescient, in that it mirrored the delusional fantasies that several of the houseguests are having.

Witness Devin and Caleb deciding that Donny was a super-secret ex-military man. Then, as at other moments, there was really fine and fun editing, such as a cut to Donny lifting a small weight in the back yard. Caleb insisted, “I ain’t stupid.”

Speaking of Caleb, there was no broadcast at all of his delusional crush on Amber, which has drawn the attention of someone who doesn’t want their byline on a story that essentially gathers dumb tweets to try to make an argument. On the live feeds last night, that crush appeared to have some resolution, so perhaps it’s already over and will never be on TV.

Back to Devin, because once again, he was the star of the arrogantly stupid assumptions, and along with a few others, is getting most of the screen time. First he insisted, “I have a huge influence on a lot of people in this house with my charm and my charisma. I think I’m the perfect guy to hold this group together.” That’s like saying tape is the perfect thing to hold a wing on a plane.

Then, when Donny’s failure to win immunity in the competition left him in tears because of the compassion he got from other players (“it’s ya’ll that’s makin’ me cry–my friends … It touches my heart”), Devin insisted that was Donny “vying for my sympathy. … I’m gonna call BS on that one. I think he’s a great actor.” Devin thinking Donny is a great actor is like thinking a tomato is a Snickers in disguise–and then throwing the tomato away because it’s such a liar.

There was a moment in the Diary Room when Devin scrunched up his face and appeared to struggle with the disparity between reality and the version of it he has in his mind. But then Donny went and won the (reused, familiar) POV competition; by actually spelling a word with several letters, he provided incontrovertible evince that he’s an undercover spy, too. How else could there be someone so smart in the Big Brother house?

Meanwhile, Nicole was “100 percent sure that there is one living in the fire room.” By “one,” she meant a ghost. She confidently believes that ghosts exist and inhabit a soundstage on CBS’ Radford lot. This gave Christine doubts about a season-long alliance, because aligning with someone who insists invisible things are real is probably a bad idea.

Perhaps the most frustrating moment came with Joey’s attempt to create an all-girl’s alliance. Although her instincts about another big alliance were correct, she’s stuck with people who are too naive, arrogant, or stupid to go along with it, never mind that she pitched it to a member of the men’s alliance, Amber. That led to Devin making faces at Joey because of her alleged stupidity, and Caleb insisting that Joey was stupid for forming an alliance this early even though he’s a member of an early alliance that will likely implode in a week or two.

Most likely, Joey exits tonight, after being voted the first member of Team America. Big Brother twists imploding on themselves: fuck yeah.

All reality blurred content is independently selected, including links to products or services. However, if you buy something after clicking an affiliate link, I may earn a commission, which helps support reality blurred. Learn more.

More great stories

About the author

  • Andy Dehnart is the creator of reality blurred and a writer and teacher who obsessively and critically covers reality TV and unscripted entertainment, focusing on how it’s made and what it means.


I value our community at reality blurred, which connects people through open and thoughtful conversations about the TV we’re watching and the stories about it.

Comment rules: My goal is for us to be able to share our perspectives and exchange ideas in a welcoming, supportive space. That’s why I’ve created these rules for commenting here. By commenting below, you confirm that you’ve read and agree to them.

Happy discussing!