Why have there been no new hit reality shows on the major broadcast networks–ABC, CBS, Fox, and NBC–in the past few years? Joe Adalian reports for Vulture and offers informed theories about why broadcast networks can’t (or won’t) make a new reality hit.
Fascinatingly, he notes that there will be just six new reality series–including Fox’s one-off knock-off of ABC’s Splash, the competition that debuts tonight–by the end of the season. Six! Between four networks! That’s because network executives are risk-averse. Also, they don’t have much room to play with, since networks don’t get as much money from advertisers for reality, and their existing shows take up a big chunk of the one-third to one-quarter of the schedule they devote to reality.
The story is worth a read for Adalian’s insight, and that of the network executives and producers he interviewed, and I’m not just saying that because he also interviewed me.
Overall, Adalian suggests there are five reasons why they: 1. Networks really try that often, 2. They make safe choices and don’t take risks, 3. Cable is doing a much better job, 4. Broadcast networks keep going back to the same few producers instead of giving others a chance, and 5. They’re ignoring documentary-style series that are so popular and successful on cable.
Ultimately, it’s not a matter of if, but when a broadcast network will try something truly new that will really take off, and putting celebrities into a competition is not something new. But they have to be willing to embrace failure first.