• reality shows
  • reality TV reviews
  • about
  • contact
  • reality TV schedule
  • best reality TV
  • send tips or feedback
  • support
  • subscribe
Survivor Samoa

Russell wins $100K for being a better character than player, but Natalie wins the game and $1M

by Andy Dehnart 21 Dec. 2009 | 9:24 am

Russell Hantz may have made Survivor Samoa, but Survivor Samoa did not make him another $1 million. Instead, he lost to Natalie White, who took the prize and title of “Sole Survivor,” even though Russell offered to buy the title from her for $100,000.

Russell did win America’s vote and $100,000 of his own, beating fan favorite runner-up Shambo (okay) and third-place Brett (What the hell? That must have been some kind of ironic vote on behalf of Internet pranksters.). But he was visibly upset thoughout the live show–and he was still pissed this morning.

Why did Natalie win? Erik summed it up in his surprising and emotional jury speech: “in an environment filled with arrogance [Russell], delusional entitlement [Mick], maybe the person who thinks she’s the least deserving is maybe the most.” Shambo and John were the only people who didn’t buy into that argument; the other seven jury members did, although their erratic Q&A–or the editing of it–made them hard to read.

I’m convinced that the fatal flaw in Russell’s game plan was there from day one, and even earlier: He never took the social game into account. (An interview with Russell’s thoughts about this is coming later today; obviously, he disagrees.) At the beginning of the episode, he referred to the others as “my puppets,” adding, “when I’m finished with them, just throw them in the trash.” You can’t treat everyone as disposable and expect them to vote for you. He was, I think, too honest, too cocky, and too confident.

Russell didn’t get how that cost him the $1 million. But he talked shit about everyone and talked himself up, and of course the jury talked amongst themselves about that, and he was better at antagonizing them than befriending them. A good example of this came during the reunion when, amusingly, he produced a pair of socks from his pocket to offer to Jaison as replacements for the ones he burned, and then hurled them into the fire. Funny, but he’s a dick, and dicks don’t get $1 million from people they’ve dicked over. Instead, they complain about not being rewarded.

Don’t get me wrong: Russell was an amazing character and a fantastic player, and I can’t wait to see him on all-stars. I was rooting for him at many points during the season, especially in that final challenge as he faced off against Brett, who would have been the worst winner ever. In a season of weak challenges–one of the immunity challenges tonight was literally running across a net and balance beam, and then assembling a puzzle–the final immunity challenge succeeded because it was the most tense endurance challenge I can recall.

But Russell wasn’t a perfect player. Those people who are upset with the jury seem to think the jury was behaving like childish, sore losers. But often, the winner is the person who does the best job of kissing the jury’s asses, even lying about why they did or said certain things. Like it or not, part of the game is making the jury feel good about their vote, not reminding them that they suck and you do not. This isn’t the first time we’ve seen a jury give the prize to someone who played less vocally; juries want their winners to be contrite, not arrogant. And even the asses form bonds. Consider Richard Hatch, who built strong friendships while he played brutally. What Rudy-like friendship did Russell have? Shambo?

Also, let’s not forget the role editing plays. During the reunion, Jeff said, “The audience overwhelmingly says Russell played the better game. The people who played with him say he did not.” In other words, Russell made great TV. Despite his obviously great moves, like finding hidden immunity idols, he did not make the greatest player.

That said, as the words I’ve written so far prove, it’s definitely easier to point out why Russell lost than why Natalie should have won. While she made moves like working to get Erik out, she wasn’t the strategist and big player that Russell was, and her win proves she knew how to play the game, even if it involved being nice and riding someone’s coattails. I don’t think that was really her only game, but even if it was, that’s a perfectly legitimate way to win Survivor.

Interestingly, Russell told me pre-game that he planned to make Natalie part of his “dumb-ass girl alliance,” but it was the jury who made him look like a dumb-ass. Probst asked Russell about those comments and said “a lot of women” found that offensive (so did a lot of men, Jeff). But Russell, arrogant once again, just said, “There’s no regrets how I played the game. I don’t regret anything I did.”

Jeff then pointed out, “One of those dumb-ass girls beat your ass.”

And that is why I love Jeff Probst. And Survivor.

discuss this story

more great reality blurred stories

  • The 20 Survivor winners who will compete on Survivor season 40
  • How Antiques Roadshow works
  • Scare Tactics: The surprising way the show was cast
  • Behind the scenes of the Guy’s Grocery Games grocery store
  • The Survivor rule book and Survivor cast contract
  • How Big Brother’s house is designed

Reality TV in your inbox

Hand-crafted reality TV news and recommendations sent most Fridays. Unsubscribe any time!

most-popular stories on reality blurred

The central cast of MTV's Ex On the Beach: Peak of Love

Ex on the Beach: Peak of Love cast includes Adore Delano and Temptation Island singles

MTV announced the cast and air date for Ex On the Beach season 4, which has relocated to the mountains of New Zealand and now has the nonsensical name of Ex On the Beach: Peak of Love.

Boston Rob Mariano and Sandra Diaz-Twine on Survivor: Island of the Idols

Survivor 40's cast of 20 Survivor winners

Survivor season 40's all-winner cast has been revealed. Original winner Richard Hatch is not competing, but nearly every winner from seasons 22 to 37 is returning.

Gabrielle Union during the America's Got Talent season 14 semifinals 2 episode

Gabrielle Union was fired from America's Got Talent. What we've learned since then about AGT's "toxic culture"

Reports have detailed a "toxic culture" at AGT that Gabrielle Union tried to address but was labeled as "difficult."

Jeff Probst on the premiere of Survivor Island of the Idols, standing next to a sign that reminds everyone what Survivor used to focus on.

Survivor season 40 will start earlier than usual

Survivor: Winners at War will premiere in February, and have a two-hour premiere.

A New Hampshire bridge in winter, which will take us from fall to spring reality TV shows

Winter 2020 reality TV schedule and guide

This winter reality show 2019 and 2020 schedule is a frequently updated list of premieres for broadcast, cable, and streaming reality TV shows, documentary series, game shows, and other prime-time nonfiction TV.

Carl Ruiz after winning the Guy's Grocery Games Diners, Drive-ins and Drives Tournament

Carl Ruiz, Guy's Grocery Games judge and champion, has died

The chef was first featured on Food Network's Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives, and later became a regular judge on Guy's Grocery Games, which he also competed on.

On Kings of Pain, Rob “Caveman” Alleva puts a tarantula hawk, a massive wasp, on Adam Thorn so it can sting him

Is Kings of Pain science or stupidity? An interview with a History Channel executive

An interview with a History Channel executive about Kings of Pain, on which two men are bitten and stung to see how much it hurts.

Fall things: pumpkins, leaves, hay, waning light, and new seasons of your favorite reality shows

Fall 2019 reality TV schedule and guide

This fall reality show 2019 schedule is a frequently updated list of premieres for broadcast, cable, and streaming reality TV shows, documentary series, game shows, and other prime-time nonfiction TV.

RuPaul and two members of RuPaul's Drag Race's Brit Crew

Why Drag Race UK proved to be a 'much betta' version

The first season of BBC Three's Drag Race UK, which aired on Logo, was a brilliant season and a bloody good time.

Survivor: 19 seasons, at least 19 naked cast members

From the site that brought us shirtless American Idol contestants and naked Real World cast members comes "A (Not So) Complete History of Naked 'Survivor' Castaways." In honor of Survivor's anniversary, YuppiePunk asks, "how better to look back on its history than how it began -- in the nude"? That history starts ...

behind the scenes of reality TV

Scott Storey in the Big Brother 15 house

How Big Brother’s set is designed: an interview with production designer Scott Storey

Emmy-winning production designer Scott Storey talks about his work on the Big Brother house, which he’s been designing since season six.

Hunted, Sentra Tran, Thu Tran

Behind the scenes of CBS’ Hunted

A person who appeared on CBS’ Hunted reveals key details about how the show works—and Channel 4’s version of Hunted also offers insight.

The Bachelor mansion, season 22

Bachelor mansion: behind the scenes

The secrets of Villa De La Vina, the candle wax-scented mansion where The Bachelor and Bachelorette are filmed.

older

Prayer warriors get snubbed by God as Shambo dumped by Foa Foa, has “no ill will”

newer >

Jaison, Mick, and Brett say Russell couldn’t win; he was “too blatantly arrogant and mean-spirited”

more stories about Survivor Samoa

discuss this story

about Andy Dehnart

Andy Dehnart’s writing and criticism about television, culture, and media has appeared on NPR and in Vulture, Pacific Standard, The Los Angeles Times, and other publications. He has covered reality television for more than 18 years, and created reality blurred in 2000.

A member of the Television Critics Association who serves on its board of directors, Andy, 41, also directs the journalism program at Stetson University in Florida, where he teaches creative nonfiction and journalism. He has an M.F.A. in nonfiction writing and literature from Bennington College. Learn more about reality blurred and Andy.

stay connected with reality TV

Get advice about what to watch and keep up with the latest in reality television with reality blurred's e-mail newsletter. Just enter your e-mail address:

about reality blurred

reality blurred is your guide to the world of reality TV and unscripted entertainment, with reality show reviews, news, and analysis. It was created in 2000 by Andy Dehnart. He's still writing and publishing it today.

reality blurred is regularly updated with highlights from the world of reality TV: news and analysis; behind-the-scenes reports; interviews with reality TV show cast members and producers; and recaps and reviews of these reality TV shows, including Survivor, Big Brother, The Great British Baking Show, Shark Tank, The Amazing Race, The Bachelor, Project Runway, Dancing with the Stars, Top Chef, and many more.

explore

  • recent news
  • reviews of reality TV shows
  • behind the scenes reports
  • interviews with producers and reality stars
  • archives
  • send tips
  • search
  • advertise on reality blurred
  • about reality blurred
  • newsletter
  • RSS and social media
  • contact reality blurred
  • send tips & contribute
  • privacy policy
  • terms of service
Copyright © 2000 to 2019 Andy Dehnart and individual contributors.