american family
amazing race 13
america's/talent 3
american idol 8
the bachelor 12

big brother 10
the biggest loser 5
celebrity apprentice
celebrity rehab
the contender 3

dancing/stars 7
deadliest catch
dirty jobs
extreme makeover
hell's kitchen 4

high school reunion
the hills
I love money
kid nation
making the band 4

the mole 3
project runway 6
nashville star 6
paradise hotel 2
real wrld hollywood

rw/rr challenge
real housewives
road rules
the surreal life 6
survivor gabon

top chef 5
top model 11
work out

> all other shows

American Idol 6

Idol producer: banter isn’t scripted, but if it was, Ryan and Simon “would have both come out”

The executive producer of American Idol denies a tabloid report’s claims that parts of the show are scripted or planned in advance.

“I don’t make notes. Simon keeps to himself in his trailer before the show with a feed, so he can listen to the music,” Nigel Lythgoe tells TMZ.

The tabloid claimed Lythgoe “watches the rehearsals and writes notes on who Simon should make snarky remarks about,” and also said that “Most of these rifts [between host Ryan Seacrest and Cowell] have been outlined.”

Lythgoe said that wasn’t true, either. “If I would have written any of that it would have been a lot funnier, to be frank. I wouldn’t have kept this gay angst going for so long. They would have both come out by now in my story,” he said.