american family
amazing race 13
america's/talent 3
american idol 7
the bachelor 12

big brother 10
the biggest loser 5
celebrity apprentice
celebrity rehab
the contender 3

dancing/stars 6
deadliest catch
dirty jobs
extreme makeover
hell's kitchen 4

high school reunion
the hills
I love money
kid nation
making the band 4

the mole 3
project runway 5
nashville star 6
paradise hotel 2
real wrld hollywood

rw/rr challenge
real housewives
road rules
the surreal life 6
survivor gabon

top chef 4
top model 10
work out

> all other shows

American Idol 4

American Idol’s performance style “may change forever the way Broadway sings.”

American Idol’s performance style “may change forever the way Broadway sings.”
American Idol’s brand of “intensely emotional and oddly impersonal” singing “may change forever the way Broadway sings,” Ben Brantley argues in The New York Times. On the show, he says, “The accent is on abstract feelings, usually embodied by people of stunning ordinariness, than on particular character. Quivering vibrato, curlicued melisma, notes held past the vanishing point: the favorite technical tricks of ‘Idol’ contestants are often like screams divorced from the pain or ecstasy that inspired them.” He finds that various aspects of Idol have trickled into Broadway performances, from a “self-congratulatory element” to the way the show “celebrates stamina, will power and gymnastic agility,” which leads contestants to “hoist, hold and balance notes like barbells in a weight-lifting exhibition. And the audience claps and hoots instinctively every time such muscle-flexing occurs.”