Members of the Television Critics Association have 48 hours to nominate shows for this summer’s TCA awards, and that includes nominating, from thin air, two reality shows. Last year, that resulted in an embarrassing list: of all the quality reality television on cable and broadcast networks, we picked the predictable, obvious, highly publicized shows.
As a public service, here’s a list of shows I think should be nominated for Outstanding Achievement in Reality Programming for the 2012 awards. Each member of TCA can each only nominate two shows per category, so this list is small by design; there are many series not on this list that I watch regularly and enjoy, and also shows I wish were here (Survivor, for example) but that didn’t do their best work in 2012.
We are, after all, TV critics: We’re supposed to make smart, informed, analytical, critical judgments. These are the series that had exceptional seasons last year and rise to the top for the exceptional ways in which they transform people’s lives or experiences, real or contrived, into compelling entertainment. Thus, they truly deserve recognition:
- Whale Wars, Animal Planet
- Top Shot, History
- The Glee Project, Oxygen
- Hoarders, A&E
- Shark Tank, ABC
- 24/7 Flyers/Rangers: Road to the NHL Winter Classic, HBO
- The Pitch, AMC
- Deadliest Catch, Discovery
- So You Think You Can Dance, Fox