In his interview with HitFix, Survivor Nicaragua winner Jud “Fabio” Birza is a bit more coherent than I’ve seen in other interviews (it’s no surprise that a jury member wrote 420 next to his name when they cast their vote), and reveals that he was surprised by how many votes Chase received, and those were probably sympathy votes that went against what the jury planned at Ponderosa.
In the interview, Fabio said, “I thought I was gonna win by more than one vote. I think some of the people on the jury did, too. I think some of them were like, ‘Holy shit, we didn’t know it was that close.'”
Why did that happen? Fabio said, “Alina told me that she wanted Chase to get a few votes, so she voted for him. Brenda did the same thing, apparently. She wasn’t decided on who she was going to vote for until she got up there. They all communicate at Ponderosa and they have a game plan and it sounds like some people just deviated from that.”
By the way, Fabio also reveals he was recruited, though he had watched the show. He said, “I’d always understood it and thought that it was a pretty cool concept and so when the casting lady hit me up, I was like, ‘Dang, you know what? I bet you I could do that.’ I was thinking about my theater training and my personality and the physicality and everything that goes with it and I was like, ‘Dude. I have to go do this, because I think I can win.'”