Producer “really mad” at Idol finalists’ song choice; Harry Connick, Jr., will mentor, arrange

On Tuesday’s American Idol performance episode, the finalists will perform Frank Sinatra songs and be mentored by Harry Connick, Jr., who Fox says “will be the first Idol mentor to arrange the songs, write the orchestrations for the contestants and perform.”

But those arrangements won’t include something we’ve seen a lot of his season: guitars. That’s because, as the L.A. Times reports, the guitar “was not allowed (per [executive producer Ken] Warwick),” because of “the Harry Connick Jr. big band thing, apparently.”

Speaking of Warwick, in late March, the theme for American Idol 9‘s changed from teen idols to Billboard #1 hits, even though a teen idol (Miley Cyrus) mentored them and teen idols performed during the results show. The reason, we’ve just learned, was because the show’s executive producer got pissed off at the finalists’ song selection.

After being voted out, Siobhan Magnus explained in an interview with the L.A. Times that executive producer Ken Warwick changed the theme:

“There was too many duplications of everything. Two people wanted Jackson 5, two wanted Michael Jackson, two wanted to do the Monkees. … [Warwick] got really mad. He was, like, ‘Never have I had so many people want the same thing!’ So after we’d been rehearsing all day, everything got halted everything, and we had to wait for a few hours while they made a new list of songs. It had never been done before, but the theme was changed to Billboard No. 1 hits.”

Siobhan Magnus explains the ill-fated ‘Teen Idols’ week, takes issue with ‘scream’ label, more at ‘Dream’ house [Los Angeles Times]

discuss this story